Two kinds of good bible study question – and the critical difference

2

27/06/2013 by Chris Green

Bible study questionsYou’ve probably been in a bible study where the leader asks a question and there’s that awkward silence. Is the question too hard, too easy, or too badly phrased? Often it’s down to the kind of question that’s been asked.

In particular, we need to know the difference between an open and a closed question.

A closed question is simple, direct, and has only one right answer. For instance, ‘What had been Onesimus’s position in Philemon’s household?’ It’s a good question, because knowing his status (a slave) is the key to understanding the letter.

But it’s not a good discussion question. Why? Because the moment someone answers it, everyone else in the group shuts up. It’s the right answer. And at best, you have to ask another question. And another. And before long the Bible study has become a quiz, with you asking a question and the bright kids in the class finding the right answer first. Not good.

It’s also not a very difficult question. It comes right off the page – so you might have a silence because people suspect it’s a trick question. ‘Well, it’s obvious that he’s a slave but I’m not going to say that because I’ve probably missed something more subtle’.

Or, if you’re dealing with people who don’t know their bibles very well, it might even be too difficult: ‘Who are these people with impossible names? I’ve never heard of either of them before.’

An open question, by contrast, is one where there is more than one right answer. Take a breath – I’m not saying that all answers are right, just that there are some questions which allow some exploration and discussion.

For instance: ‘In what ways had Onesimus’s conversion affected his relationship with Philemon?’ Now, simply by using the plural (‘in what ways’) I’ve flagged up that there’s more than one answer here, and I’m allowing people to dig into the text. More than that, we can spend five minutes on one answer, and then I can gather us all back on the track. ‘OK, has anybody found another way that his conversion affected their relationship?’

Or: ‘Why do you think Philemon would find this letter hard?’ That’s also open, but this time I’m allowing different members of the group to express an opinion, right out of the text but impacting them. So it leads into application.

I was in one memorable bible study where the leader had only one question, and kept asking us to look closer into the passage to find more and more answers. It was hard work, but fun!

There are two implications for our preparation.

1. We’re probably going to need both open and closed questions. Sometimes we need to gather information and get some facts in public. Closed questions are great for that. Don’t run away from them, but remember they are a particular kind of tool.

2. Good open questions will mean that you can probably predict a number, or even all, the right answers, but not the order they’ll come in. You therefore need to take a more ‘guiding’ role to your leadership. Nudge people towards the verse they’ve overlooked, be open to someone spotting something you haven’t, or putting it in different words to yours. That’s OK –this is a Bible Study, not an exercise in reading your mind!

I’m going to think more about that ‘guiding’ role in the next post.

Have you seen some good examples of Open Questions? Share them in the comments section below.

Details of The Message of the Church here.

2 thoughts on “Two kinds of good bible study question – and the critical difference

  1. Levi says:

    Thanks for that Chris. You’ve pulled together some stuff I’ve been trying to get my head around recently. I wonder if it’s better to use the answers to the closed questions as statements to kick off more open discussion? E.g. “Onesimus was previously one of Philemon’s slaves: how might that affect their relationship now?”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Publication of The Goldilocks Zone

Launch dayJanuary 18th, 2018
33 days to go.

Living as a Christian in the 21st century means we face constant battles to please God. That’s why I wrote ‘PURITY: Living to please God in an impure world – 15 daily readings in 1 Thessalonians.’

There’s only way to get it – by subscribing to my  email newsletter here.

Topics

God, Suffering and Joy

A conversation between me (with cancer) and Michael (with Multiple Sclerosis)

Terms and conditions

This blog does not share personal information with third parties nor do I store any information about your visit to this blog other than to analyse and optimise your content and reading experience. I am not responsible for republished content from this blog on other blogs or websites without my permission. This privacy policy is subject to change without notice.

I welcome your participation on the Ministrynutsandbolts site, and invite you to share ideas elsewhere on what you learn and read here. At the same time, I ask that you respect my intellectual property rights in the process.

You are welcome to link to my site or any specific post on my site, extract and re-post less than 200 words on any other site, provided you link back to my original post, or print my posts in any non-commercial publication (e.g., company newsletter, class syllabus, church newsletter, etc.), provided you include this copyright notice: “© 2017 Chris Green. All rights reserved. Originally published at www.ministrynutsandbolts.com.”

Please do not do the following without written consent: Re-post one of my posts in its entirety anywhere else on the Internet, use this content for commercial purposes, including selling or licensing printed or digital versions of my content, or alter, transform, or build upon this work.

If you have some use for my content that is not covered here, please contact me. If you would like me to do a guest post on your blog, email me at ministrynutsandbolts@gmail.com

Copyright does not apply to the titles of books, but transparency means I should own that the title of the blog is taken from the excellent ‘Ministry Nuts and Bolts: What They Don’t Teach Pastors in Seminary ‘ by Aubrey Malphurs (Kregel: 2nd edn. 2009)

© 2017 Chris Green

%d bloggers like this: