“I’m your bible study leader – read my mind”


09/07/2013 by Chris Green

mind reading, bible study

A friend was once in what she called ‘bible study by mind-reading’. The leader had some questions – and the right answers – on a piece of paper, and the group was only allowed to look at Question 2 when it had correctly answered Question 1. ‘Correctly’ meant using exactly the same words as on the paper. After half an hour of the group circling round, trying to get the answer exactly right, my friend exploded. ‘Oh, just tell us what the right answer is and we can move on to the next one.’ And so they did. And so the exercise of guessing what was in the leader’s mind happened again.

I think I put that down to the inexperience of the leader, who had come from a well-taught church, where group bible seminars were important, and followed a clear curriculum. There had been a prep. session, covering the questions and the answers. But this inexperienced leader, perhaps nervous at making theological errors, hadn’t realised that when a group happens it has a life of its own, and some flexibility needs to come into the planning.

Over the cycle of the study itself, there are three kinds of questions we can ask:

Discovering questions work to get people into the text, to see what’s in there, de-cluttering their preconceptions and misconceptions, so that the clear issues lie before us. You’ll need to guide people to particular sections, and prod them to see the surprises. These kind of questions provoke intense, close reading of the page. At this point we can be quite directive – although do allow people to get something half-right without squashing them, or completely right but in different words.

Understanding questions are when some pennies begin to drop. Perhaps they make a connection, or follow through on a thought. At this stage people are processing what they have discovered, exploring and analysing it – perhaps questioning it to see if what this passage seems to say is what the Bible as a whole says.

Applying questions are when the implications sink in, and the study moves into its ‘so what?’, and ‘now what?’ phases. Don’t expect any new ideas to be discovered – instead, let them chew on what they’ve discovered.

But you need to be sensitive to the speed that the group and its members are moving. Because different people think at different speeds, know different amounts, and have to unlearn different untruths. And in your enthusiasm for what you’ve unearthed you might move too quickly, and give them intellectual indigestion. So it might be wise to drop two of your four discovery questions, so that what they have discovered for themselves can be processed.

Remember – if the goal is that people learn (rather than that you teach), it’s better for them to get 50% of the way unaided, than 100% of the way carried by you. It’s often wiser to leave some of your questions unasked, and always better not to spoon-feed the answers. Slow down to their pace.

2 thoughts on ““I’m your bible study leader – read my mind”

  1. levibooth says:

    So true. I had to learn some of those lessons the hard way. What do you think about ‘feeling’ questions (i.e. “How does this make you feel?” “Is there anything you find hard to accept?”)? Would you use them? If so where would they best fit in?

    • Chris Green says:

      I think I’d use them if the passage was directed to our feelings – but also if I wanted to explore how people were reacting to the passage. It’s part of knowing the group.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Shortlisted for “Most Inspiring Leadership Blog, 2018”

New resource

Pastors are busy, and leading a church is a demanding task.  That’s why I wrote this e-bookchecklist: The Pastor’s Checkup – The Top 10 Questions every pastor needs to answer (and helpful stuff if you can’t)

There’s only way to get it is by subscribing to my  (occasional) email newsletter here.


God, Suffering and Joy

A conversation between me (with cancer) and Michael (with Multiple Sclerosis)

Legal stuff

This blog does not share personal information with third parties nor do I store any information about your visit to this blog other than to analyse and optimise your content and reading experience. I am not responsible for republished content from this blog on other blogs or websites without my permission. This privacy policy is subject to change without notice.

I welcome your participation on the Ministrynutsandbolts site, and invite you to share ideas elsewhere on what you learn and read here. At the same time, I ask that you respect my intellectual property rights in the process.

You are welcome to link to my site or any specific post on my site, extract and re-post less than 200 words on any other site, provided you link back to my original post, or print my posts in any non-commercial publication (e.g., company newsletter, class syllabus, church newsletter, etc.), provided you include this copyright notice: “© 2017 Chris Green. All rights reserved. Originally published at www.ministrynutsandbolts.com.”

Please do not do the following without written consent: Re-post one of my posts in its entirety anywhere else on the Internet, use this content for commercial purposes, including selling or licensing printed or digital versions of my content, or alter, transform, or build upon this work.

If you have some use for my content that is not covered here, please contact me. If you would like me to do a guest post on your blog, email me at ministrynutsandbolts@gmail.com

Copyright does not apply to the titles of books, but transparency means I should own that the title of the blog is taken from the excellent ‘Ministry Nuts and Bolts: What They Don’t Teach Pastors in Seminary ‘ by Aubrey Malphurs (Kregel: 2nd edn. 2009)

© 2018 Chris Green

%d bloggers like this: